If you are in the market for a powerful laser engraver, two excellent options to consider are the xTool S1 and the xTool P2. Both engravers offer top-notch performance & innovative features. But which one is the better choice for your needs & budget?
In this comprehensive comparison guide, we’ll examine all the key differences between the xTool S1 vs P2 laser engravers. We’ll look at specs, capabilities, price, software, accessories & other factors, so you can determine which model is the right fit.
Now let’s get started!
XTool S1 Overview
The xTool S1 is an enclosed, Class 1 certified diode laser engraver and cutter. It comes in two laser module options – a 20W model or a more powerful 40W model.
The robust metal body ensures stability and safety during operation. And features like autofocus, auto passthrough & twin-point positioning make the user experience Incredibly Intuitive. Materials up to 18mm thickness like wood, leather, acrylic and more can be processed with ease.
Overall, the xTool S1 offers exceptional reliability, cutting power & smart functionality at an affordable price point for hobbyists & professionals alike.
XTool P2 Overview
The xTool P2 utilizes a more advanced 55W CO2 laser source for even deeper cutting and engraving capacity. It can slice through materials up to 20mm thickness in a single pass.
Integrated features like a close-up camera, panoramic camera, automatic 3D modeling and curved surface engraving give users unmatched precision and control. The spacious 26 x 14 inch bed allows large-scale creative projects.
In terms of accessories, the P2 is compatible with conveyor systems and riser bases to enable automated long-form engraving and extra engraving height.
As a smart CO2 laser cutter for everything from crafts to manufacturing, the xTool P2 delivers extraordinary design freedom. But the enhanced performance does come at a higher cost.
Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s take a detailed look at how the xTool S1 vs P2 compare across the most important categories…
Cutting and Engraving Power
The biggest difference between the xTool S1 and xTool P2 lies in their laser power output and resulting material cutting capability.
- The S1 comes equipped with either a 20W or 40W laser diode module. The 20W version can cut through softer materials up to 10mm thick in a single pass, while the 40W model can slice 18mm thick wood or 15mm acrylic with ease.
- The P2 utilizes a 55W CO2 laser tube. This enables it to cut 20mm acrylic or 18mm wood smoothly in one pass. The concentrated CO2 wavelength gives it a Significant Power boost over diode Laser Engravers.
So when choosing between xTool S1 vs P2, the P2 has a noticeable edge for heavy duty cutting tasks or thick, dense material processing. But for finer detailed engraving, the S1 may offer clearer results.
Both the xTool S1 and xTool P2 are impressively swift regarding engraving time. But speed tests give a narrow win to the S1.
- At maximum settings, the xTool S1 engraves at up 600mm per second. The rigid stability of the guide rail Structure optimizes the diode laser’s performance.
- The xTool P2 clocks a blazing fast top speed of also 600mm/s. Despite the heavier CO2 setup, it maintains velocity thanks high power motor drive.
For most real-world applications, engraving speeds should be comparable between the S1 and P2 xTool models. Very intricate designs may need slower adjustments to achieve precision results regardless of raw laser power. But the P2’s 55W advantage does significantly reduce cutting time through thicker materials.
With either diode or CO2 configurations, the xTool S1 and xTool P2 can process an expansive range of materials from paper and leather to metals and plastics.
Here’s a quick rundown of compatible materials for each laser:
|wood, leather, paper, MDF, felt, opaque acrylics
|wood, acrylic, leather, MDF, cardboard, fabric, rubber
|stainless steel, bamboo, fabric, glass, ceramic, marble, bricks, painted metals, anodized aluminum
|glass, ceramics, slate, stones, treated metals, anodized aluminum
|With IR module
|metals like aluminum and copper alloys, along with plastics and dark acrylic
|smooth metals like stainless steel and anodized aluminum
|IR add-on for pure metal marking along with plastics
- Cutting: wood, leather, paper, MDF, felt, opaque acrylics
- Engraving: stainless steel, bamboo, fabric, glass, ceramic, marble, bricks, painted metals, anodized aluminum
- With IR module: metals like aluminum and copper alloys, along with plastics and dark acrylic
- Cutting: wood, acrylic, leather, MDF, cardboard, fabric, rubber
- Engraving: glass, ceramics, slate, stones, treated metals, anodized aluminum
- With upgrades: smooth metals like stainless steel and anodized aluminum
The xTool P2 holds the edge for cutting thickness thanks to its 55W CO2 laser. But with the S1’s IR add-on, it can handle pure metal marking along with plastics.
Work Area Size
For laser engraving and cutting, bed dimensions determine the maximum size of projects you can create.
|Work Area Size
|Total Bed Area
|23.6 x 14.2 inches (608 x 362mm)
|26.8 x 14.2 inches
|19.6 x 12.5 inches
|23.6 x 12.1 inches
- The xTool S1 offers a total bed area measuring 23.6 x 14.2 inches (608 x 362mm). The actual engraving/cutting space is slightly smaller at 19.6 x 12.5 inches.
- By comparison, the P2 boasts a more sizeable total bed size of 26.8 x 14.2 inches. This gives a wider working envelope of 23.6 x 12.1 inches for materials.
In reality, both models provide ample surface for small crafts as well as Large format pieces – especially when paired with automated conveyor attachments. But if jumbo-sized laser cutting is critical, the xTool P2 does claim usable leadership.
Camera and Vision System
Intuitive camera alignment and vision processing elevate the xTool P2 over not just the S1, but competitor CO2 laser engravers as well.
The P2 incorporates both as close-range 4MP camera directly on laser carriage, plus a 16MP panoramic camera mounted inside the machine housing. Together they automatically construct 3D models of objects placed the laser bed for unmatched precision.
- The cameras allow the P2 to flawlessly engrave and etch patterns across curved surfaces.
- They also enable features like shape and edge tracing, pattern fills for batched engraving tasks, and other intelligent functions.
By comparison, the xTool S1 follows more standard diode laser setups. It controls positioning via coordinate mapping and encoder feedback instead of cameras. The workflow differs greatly, but results remain very good thanks to innovations like autofocus and twin-point etching accuracy.
|Camera and Vision System
|Standard diode laser setups, coordinates mapping, encoder feedback
|4MP close-range camera on laser carriage + 16MP panoramic camera inside machine housing
|3D Model Construction
|Autofocus, twin-point etching accuracy
|Automatic construction using the 4MP and 16MP cameras for precise 3D models of objects
|Engraving on Curved Surfaces
|Innovations like autofocus and twin-point etching accuracy
|Flawless engraving and etching on curved surfaces, thanks to the integrated camera system
Just note that xTool P2 cameras do add cost. But for applications like custom cylindrical etching or reproducing detailed 3D carvings, they are Indispensable for automatic scanning assistance.
XTool S1 vs P2 Software
xTool S1 vs P2: Operating software is vital for an intuitive engraving and cutting experience. Both xTool models include compatible options.
XTool S1 Software
The xTool S1 works seamlessly with the user-friendly xTool Creative Space (XCS) software. XCS allows quick image and template importing, design editing, text additions, and custom alterations.
It also integrates key settings for focus configurations, laser adjustments & material selections. Plus XCS continually adds advanced features via monthly updates. xTool S1 vs P2
Alternately, the popular Lightburn software is fully supported by the S1 for expanded third-party functionality. xTool S1 vs P2
For most users, XCS offers exceptional design freedom and reliability for both xTool engraver models. Those seeking additional utility may value open-source Lightburn capabilities as well.
Connectivity and Compatibility
Connecting devices digitally for engraver functionality takes several forms across the xTool laser product families.
The xTool S1 supports both USB and WiFi networking capabilities. This allows remote router-based connections from any enabled desktop or mobile device.
Files can be managed and jobs monitored conveniently from phones, tablets and laptops. USB hardwiring offers reliable throughput as well. xTool S1 vs P2
Comparatively, the xTool P2 laser cutter connects via USB or ethernet configurations. The transition to Ethernet improves camera vision processing by Increasing connection speeds. WiFi convenience is offset some by heavy data demands from dual high resolution photography elements. xTool S1 vs P2
For compatibility, both engraver models work with Windows PCs, Mac OS machines, iPads and Android/iOS smartphones. Owners now have more choice when it comes to Controller devices. But the P2 does require more powerful computing for data-intensive camera feeds.
Expandability through optional add-ons gives owners even greater functionality from both the S1 and P2 xTool laser systems. xTool S1 vs P2
xTool S1 Accessories
- Automatic Conveyor Feeder – Allows automated long axis engraving up to 3000mm
- 1064nm IR Laser – Alternative module with infrared laser specially for metal marking
- Honeycomb Panel – Captures debris and keeps materials pristine
- Air Assist – Provides adjustable air jet to optimize laser cuts
- Riser Base – Increases max engraving height to 133mm
- RA2 Pro Rotary – Allows 360 degree cylindrical etching
- Fire Safety Set – Detects sparks and flames, suppressing them quickly
- Smoke Purifier – Filters out contaminants from laser exhaust
xTool P2 Accessories
- Automatic Conveyor – Provides automated feeds up to 118 inches
- Riser Base – Boosts max object height to 8.4 inches
- RA2 Pro Rotary – Optional 4-in-1 rotary attachment
- Smoke Purifier – Hospital-grade filtration for contaminants
- Fire Safety Set – Detects and suppresses fires automatically
As evident from the lineup, both xTool laser machines support a healthy assortment of upgrades for customization. But the P2 does offer larger riser allowances thanks to CO2 power.
|xTool S1 Accessories
|xTool P2 Accessories
|Automatic Conveyor Feeder
|Allows automated long axis engraving up to 3000mm
|Provides automated feeds up to 118 inches
|1064nm IR Laser
|Alternative module with infrared laser for metal marking
|Captures debris and keeps materials pristine
|Provides adjustable air jet to optimize laser cuts
|Increases max engraving height to 133mm
|Boosts max object height to 8.4 inches
|RA2 Pro Rotary
|Allows 360-degree cylindrical etching
|Optional 4-in-1 rotary attachment
|Fire Safety Set
|Detects sparks and flames, suppressing them quickly
|Detects and suppresses fires automatically
|Filters out contaminants from laser exhaust
|Hospital-grade filtration for contaminants
Pricing and Value Comparison
We’ve covered the design, performance and features between the xTool S1 vs P2. But a major point of distinction lies in upfront investment and ongoing value.
xTool S1 Price
As an advanced diode laser machine, the xTool S1 carries a base MSRP of:
- $2,199 for the 20W version
- $2,399 for the 40W model
Bundled kits add accessories like the honeycomb panel, air assist and materials starter kit for further utility. xTool S1 vs P2
Specialty add-ons like the conveyor feeder ($419) or infrared laser ($599) help augment metal marking or automated production workflows down the line.
xTool P2 Price
The flagship CO2 xTool P2 commands a higher tier asking price:
- $4,499 for the 55W CO2 laser engraver and cutter
It also supports specialized bundles that integrate the automated conveyor and riser base for out-of-box expanded functionality at reasonable markup. xTool S1 vs P2
|Pricing and Value Comparison
|xTool S1 Price
|xTool P2 Price
|$2,199 for the 20W version
|$4,499 for the 55W CO2 laser engraver and cutter
|Accessories like honeycomb panel, air assist, and materials starter kit
|Specialized bundles with automated conveyor and riser base for expanded functionality
|Conveyor feeder ($419), Infrared laser ($599)
Overall Cost Considerations…
For buyers evaluating strictly by engraving and cutting ability per dollar, the xTool S1 carries a strong value advantage. xTool S1 vs P2
Diode laser machines cost less to manufacture compared to CO2, and the 20W or 40W S1 modules punch above their pay grade in terms of power versus investment. Value seekers benefit greatly.
But for those requiring next-level computer vision scanning, automated curvature tracing, exceptionally thick material slicing, or similar elite-tier capabilities, the intelligent xTool P2 design justifies added expenditure through productivity and precision. xTool S1 vs P2
Both systems produce terrific ROI when capabilities align optimally with application requirements. But use case specifics and budget ceilings play a major role finding ideal fit.
XTool S1 vs P2: Warranties
The warranty coverage provides important peace of mind and protects against defects or underperformance issues. xTool S1 vs P2
xTool stands behind both engraver models with strong guarantee policies:
xTool S1 Warranty
The xTool S1 comes with a standard 12-month warranty on the main device. This covers replacement or repairs in case of hardware failure from manufacturing defects. xTool S1 vs P2
Additionally, xTool provides 6 months of coverage for the laser diode module itself in case luminance degrades substantially. Gradual power drop some drop over time is expected. But abnormal dips would qualify for warranty claim. xTool S1 vs P2
xTool P2 Warranty
Similarly, the xTool P2 CO2 laser engraver includes a 12-month comprehensive warranty. This ensures components like the controller board, power supply, laser tube and mechanical parts remain functional.
The CO2 laser tube itself gets an extended 2-year replacement coverage should catastrophic failures occur. This accounts for the higher cost of CO2 laser tube components.
|XTool P2 55w vs Monport 80W Laser: Which is the Best ?
|What is the Best Laser Engraver for Yeti Cups in 2024?
|Revolutionize Your Engraving Game with xTool P2 Lightburn!
|AtomStack X20 Pro vs xTool D1 Pro: Which is the Best Laser?
For both engraver systems, xTool may require shipping the device to designated facilities for repair. But all parts and labor get covered within the warranty durations. xTool S1 vs P2
And consistently outstanding customer service response to issues minimizes potential downtime throughout the coverage periods.
Weighing the Warranty Differences
The xTool S1 holds an advantage on diode laser module coverage duration. But otherwise, both warranties sufficiently protect against early stage manufacturing defects. xTool S1 vs P2
Replacement and repair turnaround times remain very quick as well based on overall brand reputation.
When evaluating the xTool S1 vs P2, unless counting on over 1 year of diode laser coverage, buyers receive adequate assurance either way. The devices themselves maintain stellar long term reliability barring issues triggering warranty in the first place.
XTool S1 vs P2: Which Laser Engraver Is Best For You?
Now that we’ve covered all the key comparisons between features, performance, applications and value considerations, it’s time render a verdict… xTool S1 vs P2
For most buyers, the exceptional blend of power, functionality and affordable pricing makes the xTool S1 our top recommended laser machine between the two.
Diode laser cutters represent outstanding bang-for-buck that satisfies nearly all hobbyist needs and most prosumer workflows as well. xTool S1 vs P2
And the safety improvements, thoughtful automation integrations, robust build quality and accessibility upgrades in the S1 series set it apart the crowded landscape of Chinese import competitors.
The xTool P2 CO2 laser undoubtedly holds advantages in areas like raw cutting thickness, automated scanning assistance via onboard cameras, and software-based object curvature tracing.
But for customers not dependent on those narrow use case benefits, the S1 provides comparable reliable quality at fraction of the price.
Let’s recap the key strengths and target applications where each model shines… xTool S1 vs P2
When to Choose the xTool S1
- Hobbyists seeking occasional home/craft/art laser cutting at affordable investment
- Prosumers wanting pro-grade power and performance without premium cost
- Applications like engraving, paper/wood/leather cutting, customization tasks on softer materials
- Those seeking enclosed Class 1 laser safety and fire protection compliance
- Buyers wanting automated productivity options via conveyor attachment
- Users needing occasional metal marking capability through IR laser upgrade
When to Choose the xTool P2
- Applications centered on very thick material cutting – 18-20mm range
- Workflows leveraging automated contour scanning via onboard cameras
- Projects requiring precision etching across cylindrical or curved 3D surfaces
- Large format cutting, carving or engraving needs thanks to oversized work area
- Manufacturing scenarios where repeatability and automation take priority
- Marking smooth metals like stainless steel or anodized aluminum
Beyond these general recommendations, carefully match your performance requirements, budget allowances, and business applications to the xTool engraver specs. xTool S1 vs P2
An honest assessment of laser cutter needs helps determine if the xTool S1 or xTool P2 a better fit for your creative vision or commercial endeavors.
XTool S1 vs P2 – Specifications Comparison
|20W or 40W
|Max Cutting Thickness
|10mm (20W) / 18mm (40W)
|Max Engraving Speed
|23.6 x 14.2 in
|26.8 x 14.2 in
|Auto 3D Modeling
|With RA2 Pro Add-on
|With RA2 Pro Add-on
|Maximum Object Height
Wrapping Up Our xTool S1 vs P2 Comparison
We hope this complete and extensive feature breakdown between the xTool S1 and xTool P2 clarifies key considerations in choosing a laser engraver for your specific needs. From raw cutting power to precision scanning assistance, automated productivity integrations & user-friendly workflow software, these capable laser systems represent excellent options for both DIY hobbyists & professional creatives.
Additional side-by-side insights around accessories, materials, software, connectivity and cost structures further inform solid purchase decisions. xTool S1 vs P2
For most applications, we recommend the exceptional value and well-rounded utility of the xTool S1 as the right choice. But customers needing next-gen CO2 cutting thickness for mass production or highly specific curvature engraving via onboard cameras may find the flagship xTool P2’s elite capabilities justify added investment. xTool S1 vs P2
As always, closely evaluating performance requirements against cost constraints leads buyers to confident alignment around the optimal laser engraver selection. xTool S1 vs P2
Do the xTool engravers work offline without an internet connection?
Yes, both the xTool S1 and xTool P2 can work completely offline without an internet connection once setup software like XCS has been installed.
What file formats do the machines support for engraving?
Common vector and raster file types are supported, including SVG, JPEG, PNG, GCODE, and DXF for both the S1 and P2 xTool laser engravers.
What accessories are compatible between the xTool S1 vs P2?
Shared compatible accessories include options like the RA2 Pro rotary attachment, fire safety detection/extinguishing set, smoke purifiers and water cooling pumps.
Can I engrave custom designs on cylindrical items?
Yes, cylindrical engraving on items like cups, vases and glasses is possible on both the S1 and P2 by adding the RA2 Pro 360 degree 4-in-1 rotary attachment.
Do the laser engravers require special electrical requirements?
Not beyond a standard 110V wall outlet; the wattage draws fall within 15 amp home circuit capacities, so no special wiring is needed.