Laser engravers and cutters are versatile tools that allow makers, hobbyists, artists & small business owners to engrave designs on or cut a Wide Variety of materials. Two popular desktop laser machines on the market are the XTool P2 CO2 laser engraver and the Omtech fiber laser. But how do you Know which one is right for your needs?
This Comprehensive comparison of the XTool P2 and Omtech fiber laser looks at key factors like power, work area, speed, software, applications & more. Read on to find out which Laser is the best Fit for the projects you Want to take on.
Overview of XTool P2 CO2 Laser Engraver
The XTool P2 is a 55W CO2 laser engraving machine made by XTool. Here are the key specs and features of this desktop laser cutter:
- Laser power: 55W
- Work area: 14.2 x 23.6 in (36 x 60 cm)
- Max engraving speed: 600 mm/s
- Max engraving height: 2.75 in (7 cm), expandable to 8.4 in with riser block
- Dual cameras: For 3D modeling and print monitoring
- Laser type: CO2
- Materials: Wood, acrylic, leather, paper, glass, coated metals, anodized aluminum, marble, and more
- Software: XTool Creative Space (XCS)
The XTool P2 CO2 laser stands out for its large work area, fast speed, dual camera system for 3D scanning, and curved surface engraving capabilities. It can engrave a Variety of non-metallic materials like wood, acrylic, leather & glass.
The P2 is an enclosed model with safety features like an emergency stop button, lockable lid, and smoke exhaust. It comes bundled with XCS software and is compatible with LightBurn.
Overall, the XTool P2 is a high-performing CO2 laser perfect for makers and small businesses wanting to take on demanding laser cutting and engraving projects.
Overview of Omtech Fiber Laser Engraver
The Omtech fiber laser is a compact, desktop laser engraver and cutter offered in 30W, 50W, and 60W power levels. Here are the highlights of this fiber laser machine:
- Laser power: 30W, 50W, 60W options
- Work area: 14 x 8 in (35 x 20 cm)
- Max engraving speed: NR
- Max engraving height: 2 in (5 cm)
- Laser type: Fiber laser
- Materials: Metals like stainless steel, aluminum, titanium, brass, precious metals; some plastics and wood
- Software: RDWorks, LightBurn (compatible)
A key advantage of the Omtech fiber laser is that it can engrave and cut metals, unlike the CO2 laser.The fiber laser uses a powerful focused beam that allows it to mark metals quickly and cleanly without melting.
This makes the Omtech fiber laser engraver well-suited for engraving stainless steel, anodized aluminum, titanium, and precious metals like gold and silver. It can also engrave some woods and plastics.
The Omtech is enclosed for safety and works with popular software like LightBurn. Overall, the fiber Laser is the perfect Choice for working with metal materials.
Laser Power Comparison
- XTool P2: 55W CO2 laser
- Omtech fiber laser: 30W, 50W, or 60W fiber laser
When it comes to laser power, the XTool P2 packs more power with its 55W CO2 laser tube. This gives it faster cutting speeds and the ability to cut thicker materials in a single pass.
The 30W, 50W, and 60W Omtech fiber lasers have lower wattages, but fiber lasers tend to be more efficient at transferring energy to the material’s surface. So they can mark and engrave metals cleanly without high power needs.
For cutting and engraving wood, acrylics, and other non-metals where higher power is an advantage, the more powerful XTool P2 CO2 laser has the edge. But the Omtech fiber laser has sufficient power for detailed metal engraving. XTool P2 vs Omtech Fiber Laser
Work Area Comparison
- XTool P2: 14.2 x 23.6 in (36 x 60 cm)
- Omtech fiber laser: 14 x 8 in (35 x 20 cm)
The XTool P2 boasts a larger work area with over 50% more area than the Omtech fiber laser.
The P2’s 14.2 x 23.6 inch work bed gives you the flexibility to take on bigger engraving and cutting jobs. You can work on multiple smaller pieces at the same time, or larger objects.
In contrast, the Omtech’s smaller 14 x 8 inch work table is better suited for small to medium sized engraving tasks. For anyone needing to work on larger pieces, the XTool P2’s expansive work zone is a major advantage.
- XTool P2: Up to 600 mm/s engraving speed
- Omtech fiber laser: Engraving speed NR
The XTool P2 has a max engraving speed of 600 mm/s, allowing very fast engraving passes. This Contributes to its ability to get projects done quickly.
Omtech does not provide specs on the max engraving speeds for its fiber lasers. But fiber lasers tend to have slower working speeds than CO2 lasers when engraving materials like wood.
If speed is important, the XTool P2’s 600 mm/s capability makes it the faster engraving machine overall.
- XTool P2: XTool Creative Space (XCS) + LightBurn compatible
- Omtech fiber laser: RDWorks + LightBurn compatible
The XTool P2 comes bundled with XTool’s own software, XCS, which is free and user-friendly for beginners. It also works with the popular LightBurn Software.
Similarly, the Omtech fiber laser comes with free RDWorks software and is also LightBurn compatible.
So both lasers give you software options. For simplest use, the free XCS or RDWorks are beginner-friendly choices. For advanced users, both machines can be enhanced with LightBurn’s Powerful Features.
- XTool P2 materials: Wood, acrylic, paper, leather, glass, coated metals, anodized aluminum, marble, etc.
- Omtech materials: Stainless steel, aluminum, brass, gold, silver, titanium, some wood & plastics
When it comes to compatible materials, there is a major difference between these two lasers:
- The CO2 XTool P2 can cut and engrave a wide variety of non-metallic materials like wood, acrylic, leather, paper, glass, and some coated metals.
- The fiber Omtech laser is specialized for engraving metals including stainless steel, aluminum, gold, silver, titanium, and more. It has limited use of plastics & Wood.
So the type of materials you plan to use will determine which laser is better suited. For all-around use on non-metals, the XTool P2 CO2 laser can handle the most materials.
But for metal engraving, especially for applications like labeling jewelry or industrial parts, the Omtech fiber laser is the only choice. Its focused beam is designed specifically for clean, precise metal marking.
Safety Features Comparison
Both lasers have safety features to contain the high-powered laser beam during operation.
XTool P2 safety features:
- Enclosed casing with acrylic top
- Locking lid
- Emergency stop button
- Built-in smoke exhaust
- Compatible with XTool fire prevention system
Omtech fiber laser safety features:
- Sealed metal casing
- Emergency stop button
- Protective glass top
- Air assist to reduce smoke
The enclosed case and acrylic lid on the XTool P2 provide containment while allowing you to view your work. The Omtech also contains the laser but its metal case means you cannot view engraving in progress.
Both have emergency stop buttons & smoke Controls. Optional extras like XTool’s fire prevention system help boost safety further for the CO2 laser.
Overall, both brands meet basic safety needs but the P2’s acrylic window makes for easier operation and monitoring.
Ease of Use Comparison
- XTool P2: Dual cameras for 3D modeling, autofocus, touchscreen, some automated features
- Omtech fiber laser: Manual focus, adjustable laser via control panel
Ease of use and setup is an important consideration for any laser machine. Here the XTool P2 pulls ahead with some handy features:
- Its dual cameras automatically scan objects for 3D modeling and engraving. This makes engraving Curved objects easy.
- The autofocus and touchscreen offer convenient controls.
- It has helpful automated features like the motorized Z-axis to set engraving depth.
The Omtech fiber laser requires more manual processes like focusing the laser prior to engraving. Its control panel adjusts settings like laser power, speed, and job selection. But overall it involves more hands-on work compared to the automated P2.
For new laser users or those wanting maximum convenience, the XTool P2’s innovative cameras and auto controls are useful. But experienced users may not mind the Omtech’s fully manual operation.
- XTool P2: Starts at ,4,499.00
- Omtech fiber laser: Starts at ,3,699.99 (30W model)
There is a difference in price points between these two laser options:
- The XTool P2 CO2 laser comes in at a higher starting price of ,4,499.00 for the 55W model with XCS software included.
- The Omtech fiber lasers start at ,3,699.99 for their most affordable 30W version with RDWorks software. The 50W model is ,$2,199 and the 60W is ,4,499.00.
For buyers on a tighter budget, the Omtech fiber presents the lower cost option. The XTool P2 costs more upfront but delivers strong value through its performance features and capabilities.
|How to Create a Glowforge Pencil Jig and Xtool P2 Pencil Jig|
|xTool D1 40W CO2 Laser Engravers Honest Review|
|Find 2023 Next Generation Best Portable Xtool Laser Cutter?|
|xTool Enclosure Review: Is it Best for xTool D1 Pro 20W?|
So weigh your budget against what each machine can offer in terms of power, work area, materials, and features. Paying more for the XTool P2 gets you its expanded performance while the Omtech meets basic fiber laser needs at a lower price point.
Key Differences Summary
|Machine||XTool P2||Omtech Fiber Laser|
|Laser type||CO2 laser||Fiber laser|
|Power||55W||30W, 50W, 60W|
|Work area||14.2 x 23.6 in||14 x 8 in|
|Max speed||600 mm/s engraving speed||NR|
|Materials||Wood, acrylics, leather, paper, glass, some metals||Metals, some plastics and wood|
|Software||XCS + LightBurn compatible||RDWorks + LightBurn compatible|
|Automated features||3D scanning cameras, autofocus, Z-axis||Manual focus and laser position|
|Price||Starts at $4,499.00||Starts at $3,699.99 (30W model)|
Which Laser is Best for You?
Deciding between the XTool P2 CO2 laser and an Omtech fiber laser engraver comes down to a few key considerations:
- What materials do you want to engrave? CO2 can handle non-metals while fiber lasers are for metals.
- What work area size suits your projects? The P2 gives you over 50% more space.
- Is processing speed important? The P2 offers faster top engraving speeds.
- What is your budget? Omtech fiber starts lower while the P2 has a higher starting price.
- Do you prefer automated or manual operation? The P2 has more built-in automation.
For most hobbyists and small businesses wanting to engrave and cut a wide variety of non-metallic materials, the XTool P2 is the best all-around performer with its larger work area, robust 55W power, fast speed, and helpful features like 3D scanning.
The Omtech fiber laser is the top pick strictly for metal engraving. With its precision fiber laser beam, it can create stunning marks on Stainless Steel, titanium, aluminum & more. It works on a smaller scale but excels at metal marking.
Carefully weigh your material, work area, and budget needs against the strengths of each machine. For non-metals, the feature-packed XTool P2 CO2 laser has the edge for most users. But the Omtech fiber laser can’t be matched for metal engraving quality and results.
Knowing your requirements and what each device brings to the table will lead you to the right laser engraver and cutter to take your projects to the next level.
Where to Buy XTool P2 and Omtech Fiber Lasers
You can purchase the XTool P2 CO2 laser engraver directly from XTool.
For Omtech fiber lasers, visit OmtechLaser.com to view their full line of engravers and cutters.
Most models are available in the US. Be sure to check lead times for availability. Financing options are also available for both brands.
Check out both manufacturer Websites for current pricing and full specs on the XTool P2 & Omtech’s fiber laser line.
The XTool P2 & Omtech fiber laser offer two high-performing options for Laser cutting & engraving. With the right laser for your specific needs, you can take your projects and customizations to the next level.
If you need to engrave a wide range of non-metals, require a large work area, and value speed, automation, and all-around performance, the feature-rich XTool P2 CO2 laser is the best bet for everything from hobby crafts to small manufacturing uses.
For buyers focused strictly on meticulously engraving metals and willing to work in a compact space, the specialized Omtech fiber laser cannot be beaten for its ability to precisely mark stainless steel, aluminum, titanium, and more with a powerful focused beam.
Carefully weigh the strengths and ideal applications of each laser engraver and cutter. Your projects will benefit from having the perfect machine for your Specialized Needs. With the right laser by your side, you can create incredible engraved and cut works on your desired materials.
What materials can the XTool P2 engrave?
The XTool P2 CO2 laser can engrave and cut a variety of non-metals like wood, acrylic, leather, paper, cardboard, glass, marble, plastics, rubber, and some coated metals.
What materials can the Omtech fiber laser engrave?
The Omtech fiber laser specializes in engraving metals like stainless steel, aluminum, brass, titanium, silver, gold and more. It has limited use on some plastics & Wood.
How big is the work area on the XTool P2?
The XTool P2 has a generous 14.2 x 23.6 inch work area, over 50% larger than the Omtech fiber laser’s smaller 14 x 8 inch work table.
Which laser engraver is easier to use?
The XTool P2 offers more automated features like its 3D scanning cameras and autofocus which make operation simpler, especially for beginners.
Which laser machine has the faster engraving speed?
The XTool P2 CO2 laser boasts faster maximum engraving speeds up to 600 mm/s, compared to the undisclosed speeds of the Omtech.
Spread the loveThe xtool d1 pro 40w laser engraver from … Read more
Spread the loveWhat is xTool Laser? xTool is a company … Read more