You are currently viewing xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

Laser engravers and cutters have become increasingly popular tools for hobbyists, small businesses, and professional workshops. Two of the most prominent models on the market are the xTool P2 and the Laguna PL 12|20. In this Comprehensive xTool P2 review, we’ll dive deep into the features, capabilities & performance of these two machines, helping you make an informed decision about which one is right for your needs.

Power and Cutting Capabilities

xTool P2

The xTool P2 is a powerhouse in the laser engraving and cutting world. Equipped with a robust 55W CO2 laser tube, this machine can effortlessly cut through 18mm black walnut and 20mm acrylic in a single pass. Its impressive cutting speed allows it to slice through 3mm basswood at a remarkable 35mm/s, which is six times faster than a typical 20W diode laser.

Laguna PL 12|20

While not as powerful as the xTool P2, the Laguna PL 12|20 is no slouch. Its 40W CO2 laser can cut through materials up to 1/4″ thick, including wood, acrylic, and several other materials. Impressive engraving capabilities are another feature of the PL 12|20, which yields flawless lithography on the majority of non-metallic materials.

Winner: xTool P2

With its higher wattage and faster cutting speeds, the xTool P2 emerges as the clear winner in terms of raw power and cutting capabilities.

Engraving and Precision

xTool P2

One of the standout features of the xTool P2 is its dual 16MP cameras and intelligent algorithms. These cameras work in tandem to construct accurate 3D models of curved objects, Enabling Flawless curved surface engraving. The close-range camera synchronizes with the laser head, ensuring distortion-free imaging and impeccable accuracy down to 0.3mm, perfect for intricate details.

Laguna PL 12|20

The Laguna PL 12|20 is no slouch when it comes to precision engraving either. Equipped with the RUIDA RDWorks control software (with the option to upgrade to Lightburn), it can produce detailed engravings with ease. However, it lacks the advanced curved surface engraving capabilities of the xTool P2.

Winner: xTool P2

Thanks to its intelligent camera system and advanced software, the P2 takes the lead in engraving precision and curved surface capabilities.

Work Area and Productivity

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

xTool P2

The xTool P2 boasts an impressive work area of 26″ x 14″, which is 50% larger than many competitors. This generous bed size allows for bigger projects & increased productivity. Additionally, the optional automatic conveyor feeder enables seamless engraving and cutting of materials up to 118″ long without interruptions or misalignments.

Laguna PL 12|20

The Laguna PL 12|20 has a respectable work area of 12″ x 20″, with a 12″ Z-axis to accommodate larger materials and a rotary device. Its bottomless design allows for engraving on large projects like tabletops & murals.

Winner: xTool P2

With its significantly larger work area, automatic conveyor feeder & faster engraving speeds, the xTool P2 offers superior productivity and flexibility for larger projects.

Beam Precision and Accuracy

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

Precision and accuracy are crucial factors when it comes to laser engraving and cutting. Both machines handle this well, but the xTool P2 has an edge with its advanced camera system.

xTool-P2:

The dual 16MP cameras on the xTool P2 provide unparalleled precision. The close-range camera syncs with the laser head for distortion-free 0.3mm vision accuracy. This allows incredibly intricate details and patterns.

Laguna PL 12|20:

While very capable, the Laguna lacks the xTool’s advanced camera assistance. Its vision precision is around 1mm with just the single 5MP camera and standard laser alignment.

Winner: xTool P2

With its dual 16MP camera system and 0.3mm vision precision, the P2 provides unmatched accuracy and detail down to the smallest intricacies.

Speed

When it comes to speed, both machines are highly capable, but the xTool P2 has a clear advantage in terms of raw cutting and engraving speeds.

xTool-P2 Speeds:

  • Cutting Speed: Up to 35mm/s on 3mm basswood (6x faster than 20W diode lasers)
  • Engraving Speed: Up to 600mm/s

The xTool P2’s cutting speed of 35mm/s on 3mm basswood is remarkable, allowing you to process thin wood materials at blistering speeds. Its maximum engraving speed of 600mm/s is also extremely fast, thanks to its sturdy construction and high-quality motors.

Laguna PL 12|20 Speeds:

  • Cutting Speed: Up to 500mm/s
  • Engraving Speed: Up to 500mm/s

While the Laguna PL 12|20 is no slouch with cutting and engraving speeds up to 500mm/s, it simply can’t match the blistering pace of the xTool P2, especially when it comes to cutting thin materials like basswood.

Winner: xTool P2

In the speed category, the P2 is the clear winner. Its ability to cut through 3mm basswood at 35mm/s and engrave at an ultrafast 600mm/s gives it a significant advantage over the Laguna PL 12|20 in terms of sheer speed and productivity.

Whether you’re running a small business that needs to churn out products quickly or a hobbyist who values efficiency, the xTool P2’s speed capabilities allow you to complete jobs faster and with less downtime, ultimately saving you time and money.

Software and User Experience

xTool-P2

The xTool P2 comes bundled with the XCS software, which is free and regularly updated with new features like AI drawing and image tracing. This user-friendly software supports one-click operations for importing images, adding outlines, and adjusting engraving and cutting settings. The software is compatible with PC, iPad & mobile devices, ensuring a seamless workflow regardless of your preferred platform.

Laguna PL 12|20

The Laguna PL 12|20 ships with the RUIDA RDWorks control software, which is a capable and intuitive program for controlling the laser engraver. However, it lacks some of the advanced features and cross-platform compatibility of the XCS software.

Winner: xTool P2

The xTool P2’s XCS software, with its frequent updates, AI-assisted features, and cross-platform compatibility, provides a more streamlined and future-proof user experience.

Camera Assistance and Image Processing

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

The P2 has a significant advantage with its dual 16MP camera system and intelligent algorithms for 3D modeling and image tracing.

xTool-P2:

  • Dual 16MP panoramic and close-range cameras
  • Automatically constructs 3D models of curved objects
  • Intelligent shape recognition to batch engrave multiple objects
  • Advanced XCS software with AI image tracing

Laguna PL 12|20:

  • Single 5MP camera for basic alignment
  • No curved surface modeling
  • Limited shape recognition capabilities
  • Standard laser control software

Winner: xTool P2

The xTool’s dual cameras, 3D curved object modeling, shape recognition, and AI-assisted image tracing deliver innovative guidance lacking in the Laguna.

Supported Materials

Both laser engravers can work with a wide variety of materials for cutting and engraving. However, the xTool P2’s higher wattage gives it an advantage with thicker materials.

xTool-P2: Wood, acrylic, leather, rubber, fabric, glass, ceramic, slate, coated metal, anodized aluminum and more up to 20mm thick.

Laguna PL 12|20: Wood, acrylic, plywood, MDF, particle board, melamine, glass, leather, cork, ceramic, and more up to 6mm (1/4″) thick.

Material Compatibility Chart

MaterialxTool P2 (55W)Laguna PL 12|20 (40W)
WoodUp to 18mmUp to 6mm (1/4″)
AcrylicUp to 20mmUp to 6mm (1/4″)
LeatherUp to 6mmUp to 6mm
GlassEngravableEngravable
MetalCoated/AnodizedCoated/Anodized

Safety and Environmental Considerations

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

xTool-P2

Safety is a top priority for the xTool P2. It features an enclosed design with a light-filtering lid to prevent light & smoke leakage. The machine also includes an automatic lid lock during operation, an emergency stop button & a multiple-warning system for monitoring temperature, cooling water levels, and other potential issues. Additionally, the xTool P2 is compatible with an optional fire safety set for automatic fire detection and extinguishing.

In terms of environmental impact, the P2 has a built-in 145CFM exhaust fan for efficient smoke removal, and an optional smoke purifier is available for indoor use, filtering out 99.7% of particles.

Laguna PL 12|20

The Laguna PL 12|20 also prioritizes safety, with features like an exhaust fan and recommended breaker requirements. However, it lacks some of the advanced safety features found in the xTool P2, such as automatic lid locking and fire detection/extinguishing systems.

Winner : xTool P2

When it comes to environmental and user safety, the P2 leads the way with its extensive safety features, which include an optional fire safety set and effective smoke filtration choices.

Pricing and Accessories

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

xTool-P2

The xTool P2 55W CO2 Laser Cutter Productivity Bundle, which includes the laser cutter, automatic conveyor feeder, and riser base, is priced at $4,499 USD. Additional accessories like the rotary engraving attachment, smoke purifier, and fire safety set are available for purchase separately.

Laguna PL 12|20

The Laguna PL 12|20 laser engraver and cutter have a base price of $5,999. This includes the laser machine, water chiller, air pump, exhaust fan, and multiple work surfaces. Additional accessories like the rotary, stand, and tube replacements can be purchased separately.

Winner : xTool P2

Although both Engraver have a variety of attachments & configuration choices, the P2 package offers a more complete feature set at a more affordable price, making it a more economical alternative for most customers .

Noise Output

Laser machines can produce significant noise during operation. Both units have measures to reduce noise, but the xTool has an advantage.

xTool-P2:

  • Enclosed design with light-filtering lid contains noise
  • No specified dB rating, but enclosed design muffles sound

Laguna PL 12|20:

  • No enclosure, noise from motors and ventilation fans
  • 72 dB during operation according to specs

Winner: xTool P2

The fully enclosed design with light-filtering lid helps contain noise better than the more open Laguna, likely making the xTool quieter during operation.

Comparison Table

FeaturexTool P2Laguna PL 12 20
Laser Power55W CO240W CO2
Bed Size26″ x 14″12″ x 20″
Max. Engraving Speed600mm/s500mm/s
Max. Working Height72mm (275mm with riser)12″ (304mm)
CameraDual 16MP5MP
Vision Precision0.3mm1mm
Rotary Engraving Diameter0-180mm30-74mm
Auto-passthroughYes (with conveyor feeder)No
Curved Surface EngravingYesNo
Bundled Price$4,499$5,999

Final Verdict (xTool P2 Review)

After an in-depth analysis of both laser engravers, the P2 emerges as the clear winner in this head-to-head comparison. With its powerful 55W laser tube, larger work area, intelligent camera system, advanced software, comprehensive safety features & more affordable pricing, the P2 offers exceptional value and performance for hobbyists, small businesses & professional workshops alike.

While the Laguna PL 12|20 is a capable machine in its own right, the xTool P2’s impressive cutting and engraving capabilities, combined with its user-friendly interface and future-proof design, make it a top choice for anyone in the market for a high-quality laser engraver and cutter.

Whether you’re looking to create intricate designs, personalize products or explore new creative avenues, the P2 is a versatile & powerful tool that will undoubtedly elevate your projects to new heights. With its robust feature set and excellent performance, the xTool P2 is an excellent investment for anyone seeking a reliable, precise, and efficient laser engraving and cutting solution.

Also read:
Is xTool P2 All in 1 Bundle Best Laser Engraver Module Ever?
xTool P2 vs Omtech Pro 2440: Which CO2 Laser Engraver is Best in 2024?
Best OMTec 2024 CO2 Laser Engraver Machine Under $10k- OMTech PRO 2440
Best 5 Laser 100w CO2 Engravers For Small Business in 2024

My Opinion: Which should you choose?

xTool P2 vs Laguna PL 12|20: Head-to-Head Comparison in 2024

If I had to choose between these two laser engravers/cutters, I would go with the P2. Its combination of high laser power, large work area, innovative curved engraving, affordable pricing & the potential to add useful accessories like the conveyor and rotary make it an extremely versatile and capable machine.

While the Laguna has some nice included components like the chiller and exhaust, the xTool’s superior speed, software, and unique features like curved surface mapping give it an edge in my opinion. The Larger work area also Provides more options for bigger Jobs.

Of course, the final decision depends on your specific needs & budget. But for an all-around powerful laser cutter/engraver with professional-grade performance at a reasonable price point, the xTool P2 is an excellent choice that provides exceptional value. Its Innovative technologies futureproof it as a great Investment.

:FAQs:

Does xTool P2 have WiFi?

Yes, the xTool P2 supports WiFi connectivity in addition to USB and Ethernet connections. This allows you to wirelessly send jobs to the laser from your computer, tablet or mobile device for a flexible workflow.

How heavy is the xTool P2?

The xTool P2 laser cutter itself weighs 150 lbs (68 kg). When including all components like the conveyor feeder in the full bundle, the total shipping weight is 230 lbs (104 kg).

What materials can the xTool P2 cut?

The powerful 55W CO2 laser in the xTool P2 can cut through a wide variety of materials including:

Wood up to 18mm thickness
Acrylic up to 20mm
Leather up to 6mm
Rubber, fabric, MDF, and more

How thick can the xTool P2 cut?

The maximum cutting thickness of the xTool P2 is 20mm for acrylic and 18mm for hardwoods like black walnut when using 100% laser power. It can easily cut 6mm basswood at remarkable speeds.

Does xTool P2 have air assist?

Yes, the xTool P2 does include an air pump that provides air assist to help clear smoke and debris during cutting and engraving for improved quality.

Does the xTool P2 have a camera?

Absolutely, the xTool P2 has an advanced dual camera system – a 16MP panoramic overview camera and a 16MP close-range camera that synchronizes with the laser head. These cameras enable intelligent curved surface modeling, shape detection & incredible 0.3mm vision precision.


Leave a Reply