When looking to purchase a desktop laser cutter or engraver, two of the top options are the xTool P2 CO2 laser cutter and the jpt 50w fiber laser. Both machines offer powerful laser cutting & engraving Capabilities for hobbyists, entrepreneurs and small businesses. But they utilize different laser technologies and have Varying specifications & features that make them suited for different applications. In this comparisons guide, we’ll analyze the key differences between the xTool P2 CO2 laser and jpt 50w fiber laser, and help determine which is the better investment based on your needs.
Laser Source Comparison
The fundamental difference between these machines lies in the laser source technology they use:
- xTool P2: Uses a 55W CO2 laser tube. CO2 lasers emit light in the infrared spectrum at a wavelength of around 10 micrometers. This laser type can cut and engrave materials like wood, acrylic, leather, fabric, paper, cardboard and some metals and ceramics.
- jpt 50w fiber laser: Uses a 50W fiber laser module. Fiber lasers utilize glass fibers doped in rare-earth elements and emit light at near-infrared wavelengths around 1 micrometer. jpt 50w fiber lasers are suitable for engraving and cutting metal materials like stainless steel, aluminum, copper, brass, and titanium.
So while both are powerful desktop laser systems, they are intended for processing different types of materials. The xTool P2 CO2 laser works great for organic materials, while the jpt 50w fiber laser excels at metal materials.
Cutting Power and Speed
When it comes to cutting thicker and denser materials in one pass, the jpt 50w fiber laser clearly has an advantage over the xTool P2. Here’s how their Laser Cutting capabilities compare:
xTool P2 CO2 Laser Cutting Power
- 18mm Black Walnut in one pass
- 20mm clear acrylic in one pass
- Up to 10mm plywood at high speed
jpt 50w Fiber Laser Cutting Power
- Stainless steel up to 1mm
- Anodized aluminum up to 8mm
- Copper up to 6mm
- Brass up to 10mm
So the 50W fiber laser module in the jpt 50w fiber laser enables it to slice through metals up to 10mm thick, whereas the xTool P2 tops out at around 20mm for softer acrylic materials.
In terms of speed, the xTool P2 actually exceeds the max engraving speed of the jpt 50w fiber laser.
- xTool P2 max engraving speed: 600mm/s
- jpt 50w fiber laser max marking speed: 7,000mm/min or 116mm/s
So for quickly engraving patterns and designs into wood, acrylic, leather, or other organic materials, the xTool P2 is over 5 times faster than the jpt 50w fiber laser. But for metals processing, the jpt 50w fiber laser remains the top performer.
Work Area Size Comparison
The xTool P2 boasts one of the largest work bed areas you’ll find in a desktop CO2 laser, offering over 50% more capacity than typical competitive units.
- xTool P2 bed size: 26 x 14 inches
- jpt 50w fiber laser marking area:
- 110 x 110mm (small)
- 150 x 150mm
- 175 x 175mm (large)
So with its expansive 26 x 14 inch bed, the xTool P2 provides significantly more work room for taking on large-format engraving and cutting projects. Even the biggest 175 x 175mm model jpt 50w fiber laser has just a fraction of the total work area.
Camera and Software Features
The xTool P2 sets itself apart from the jpt 50w fiber laser and other competitors with its innovative built-in camera and software functions for automated and precision processing.
The key highlights include:
- Dual 16MP smart cameras for automated focusing, 3D modeling, and more
- Curved surface engraving capabilities
- Intelligent shape and batch pattern engraving
- Precision engraving and cutting using camera registration
- Free XCS laser software with advanced features and mobile app controls
The jpt 50w fiber laser utilizes EZCAD2 laser software, which provides the basic functionality for importing artwork and executing laser jobs. But the xTool P2 takes laser software to the next level for simplifying complex tasks & enhancing overall ease-of-use, especially for novice users.
Fume Extraction and Filtration System
Both laser cutters require some type of fume extraction and filtration system to manage the smoke and debris produced from laser processing various materials.
The xTool P2 comes equipped with a built-in 145CFM exhaust fan, which works effectively for venting smoke outside through a window. For indoor laser use, xTool offers a compatible Smoke Purifier accessory that filters particulates down to 0.3 microns, removing 99.7% of smoke particles.
The jpt 50w fiber laser does not include any integrated fume extraction or filtration. Either an exhaust fan or filtration system will need to be purchased separately to operate it safely indoors.
So the xTool P2’s exhaust fan and available smoke purification accessory make it the better out-of-box solution for venting and filtering laser fumes.
Beyond the basic laser cutter itself, xTool and jpt 50w fiber laser offer some useful accessories and add-ons to expand capabilities:
xTool P2 Accessories
- Automatic Conveyor Feeder – for continuous engraving/cutting up to 118 inches
- RA2 Pro Rotary Attachment – for cylindrical engraving
- Riser Base – increases max material height to 8.4 inches
- Fire Prevention Set – detects flames and extinguishes fires
jpt 50w fiber laser Accessories
- Rotary chuck options – for engraving rings, tubes, cups, etc
- Various lens options – 110 x 110mm, 150 x 150mm, 175 x 175mm
- Cooling water chiller
This allows both machines to tackle specialized engraving and cutting tasks beyond just flat workpieces. And while the jpt 50w fiber laser can be equipped with rotary attachments, the xTool P2 accessories facilitate automated workflows that boost productivity.
Due to the CO2 and fiber laser technologies utilized, the xTool P2 and jpt 50w fiber laser are intended to process different types of source materials:
- Wood (plywood, walnut, birch, oak, etc)
- Acrylic & Plastics
- Ceramic & Stone
- Painted/Coated Metals
- Anodized Aluminum
So it can cut, engrave, and mark a wide range of organic materials from wood and acrylic to leather and even some metals like anodized aluminum or powder coated metals.
jpt 50w fiber laser
- Stainless Steel
- Anodized Aluminum
- Copper and Brass
- Other Metals
The 50 watt fiber laser is specifically designed to work with bare metals and metal alloys. This Includes stainless steel, aluminum, copper, brass & more.
So in summary, if you’ll primarily be cutting and engraving wood, acrylic, leather, glass, stone, etc, the xTool P2 CO2 laser is likely the better fit. But for metals processing applications, a jpt 50w fiber laser is the clear choice.
Operating any high-power laser system requires safety considerations. Both xTool and jpt 50w fiber laser have implemented safety mechanisms to help prevent hazards and accidents:
xTool P2 Safety Features
- Automatic lid lock during operation
- Emergency stop button
- Overtemperature, water flow, and error warning system
- Compatible with fire safety detection & suppression kit
- Class 1 low-power laser variant available
jpt 50w Fiber Laser Safety Features
- Dual-button emergency stop
- Warning lights indicate emission status
- Overtemperature error protection
- Requires external water chiller for cooling laser source
So while both machines have emergency stop buttons, warning systems, and overprotection temperature, the xTool P2 offers advanced capabilities like automatically locking the lid during jobs and optional fire prevention accessories.
Overall though, both are designed as Class 1 or Class 4 enclosed laser systems that you should never operate with panels removed or disabled safety mechanisms.
As professional-grade laser cutters packing the latest technology and capabilities, both the xTool P2 CO2 laser and jpt 50w fiber laser engraver represent significant investments for any small business, school, or private individual.
Here is an overview of the hardware cost for both baseline machines:
xTool P2 CO2 Laser Cutter
jpt 50w Fiber Laser Engraver
- $5,699. (basic 175 x 175mm model)
So the 55 watt xTool P2 CO2 Laser Cutter is approximately $1200 cheaper upfront.
However, to operate safely and access upgraded features, expect to spend $4000 – $6,000+ more on additional accessories:
- Exhaust fan/filter system
- Rotary attachment
- Larger lenses or lenses with higher focal depth
- Cooling water chiller (required)
Whereas the critically-acclaimed xTool P2 ships with integrated fume extraction and offers bundled packages with productivity-expanding accessories included:
- P2 Productivity Bundle – 4,999 with auto-feed conveyor & riser base
- P2 Pro Bundle – $5,799 with conveyor, riser base, AND RA2 Pro rotary toolkit
So when factoring in all the start-up costs beyond just the laser cutters themselves, you’ll likely invest over 5,000 to get a fully outfitted metals-capable jpt 50w fiber laser workstation versus 4,500 to 5,500 for a decked out xTool P2 CO2 laser workstation.
xTool P2 vs jpt 50w Fiber Laser Comparison
Certainly! Here’s the table with the provided data:
|jpt 50w Fiber Laser
|Max Material Cut Thickness
|20mm acrylic 18mm wood
|1mm steel 10mm brass 8mm aluminum
|Max Engraving Speed
|Work Area Size
|26 x 14 in
|175 x 175 mm
|Curved engraving Intelligent batch processing Advanced features
|Basic design and execution
|145 CFM fan (built-in) Optional smoke purifier
|Requires external system
|Woods Acrylics Fabrics Leather Glass Painted metals
|Metals (steel, aluminum, brass, etc)
|Enclosure monitoring Automatic lid lock Emergency stop button
|Warning lights Emergency stop
Verdict: xTool P2 vs jpt 50w Fiber Laser
In conclusion, for larger format engraving, cutting, and marking applications on wood, acrylic, fabrics, leather, and other organic materials, the xTool P2 55W CO2 Laser Cutter is the best overall option combining expansive work area, unrivaled speed, innovative camera-guided functions, safety mechanisms, and accessories for enhancing productivity and profits.
However, for a compact yet extremely powerful laser machine tailored specifically for precision engraving, cutting, and marking metals and metal alloys, the jpt 50w fiber laser simply can’t be beaten, offering deeper penetration into stainless steel, aluminum, titanium, and other metals with advanced features like built-in rotary attachments.
So choosing between the xTool P2 or jpt 50w fiber laser engraver depends primarily on your applications and materials – CO2 for organics like wood and acrylic or fiber for metals processing. Use this breakdown of key factors as guidance to determine the right desktop laser cutting and engraving system to take your business to the next level!
What materials can the xTool P2 laser cutter engrave?
The xTool P2 can engrave, cut, and mark materials such as wood, acrylic, leather, fabric, paper, cardboard, glass, coated metals, anodized aluminum, stone, ceramic, and more.
What thickness of steel can a jpt 50w fiber laser cut?
The jpt 50w fiber laser can slice through stainless steel and carbon steel up to 1mm thick, allowing it to take on light sheet metal cutting and engraving applications.
What accessories are available for the xTool P2?
Useful accessories for the xTool P2 include automatic conveyor feeders up to 118 inches long for continuous processing, a riser base to increase max material height to 8.4 inches, rotary attachments for cylindrical engraving, and a fire safety detection and suppression set.
Does the jpt 50w fiber laser require any additional cooling?
Yes, the 50 watt laser tube in the jpt fiber laser requires an externally connected water chiller, which circulates cooled distilled water to prevent overheating.
Can you engrave curved surfaces with the jpt 50w fiber laser?
No, the jpt 50w fiber laser does not explicitly support engraving on curved surfaces – flat workpieces are required. But cylindrical engraving can be achieved with the optional rotary attachment.