Investing in a CO2 laser engraver can take your design and creation abilities to an entirely new level. With the power to precisely cut and engrave materials like wood, acrylic, leather, glass and more, a desktop CO2 laser opens up many new opportunities for makers, crafters and small business owners.
When it comes to finding the best CO2 laser engraver in 2024, two models stand out from the competition – the XTool P2 55W and the Monport 80W Laser. Both offer exceptional functionality & Value in compact desktop packages. But which one is right for you?
This in-depth guide compares every aspect of the XTool P2 & Monport 80W CO2 laser engravers to help you decide. We’ll look at:
- Key specs and capabilities
- Hardware design and features
- Software and connectivity
- Ease of use
- Safety features
- Customer support and warranty
- Pricing and value
So whether you’re new to laser engraving or a seasoned pro looking to upgrade, read on to find the perfect laser engraver to unleash your creativity in the new year and beyond!
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Key Specifications
Let’s kick things off by looking at how the core specifications of the XTool P2 55W and Monport 80W laser engravers stack up:
|XTool P2 55W
|Wood, acrylic, leather, glass, paper, fabrics, rubber, tile, slate, coated metals, anodized aluminum
|Wood, acrylic, glass, leather, paper, cardboard, textiles, rubber, stone
|Max. Engraving Speed
|Max. Cutting Speed
|Glass CO2 laser tube
|Glass CO2 laser tube
|26.8 x 14.2 in (680 x 360 mm)
|36 x 24 in (915 x 610 mm)
|Dual 16MP (panoramic + close-up)
|WiFi, USB, Ethernet
|Windows, Mac, iOS, Android
|XTool Creative Space
|RDWorks, LightBurn, CorelLaser, etc. (not included)
|PNG, JPG, JPEG, BMP, SVG, DXF
|AI, BMP, DXF, GIF, HPGL, JPEG, PDF, PLT, PNG, RD, SVG, TIFF, TGA
As you can see, the XTool P2 55W and Monport 80W CO2 laser engravers have comparable power and performance suitable for professional-grade cutting and engraving work.
The Monport 80W Laser model boasts 20% higher peak power at 80W, along with a pass-through slot for larger and longer workpieces. Meanwhile, the 55W XTool P2 counterbalances with smarter features like a dual camera setup for precision auto-focusing, curved surface engraving and wide OS and software compatibility.
Now let’s take a closer look at the hardware design and capabilities of each laser engraving machine.
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Hardware Design & Features
The hardware design and included features have a big impact on these machines’ functionality, workspace ergonomics and overall user experience.
Size & Portability
While both the XTool P2 55W and Monport 80W have similar engraving areas, the Monport 80W Laser has a notably larger overall machine footprint:
- XTool P2 55W – 28 x 16 x 16 in (700 x 400 x 400 mm), 82 lbs
- Monport 80W – 57 x 43 x 35 in (1450 x 1100 x 900 mm), 396 lbs
So if you’re tight on space or want something easier to transport or reposition, the more compact XTool P2 has an advantage. Its Lighter Weight also makes it simpler to move around.
However, the Monport 80W’s larger size allows fitting bigger workpieces through its pass-through slot, which measures a full 95 cm long and 7.5 cm high. So if you’ll be regularly working with longer planks, tubes or other larger materials, the Monport 80W Laser can handle them with less cutting and precision placement.
Build quality is also quite different between these two CO2 laser engraving machines:
- The XTool P2 55W has an all-metal enclosure and steel base plate with aluminum slats, giving it a very sturdy and stable feel. Fit and finish is excellent with no rough edges or hardware flaws.
- The Monport 80W Laser is made from a mix of metal and engineered wood panels. Reviewers have noted some slightly loose fittings and hardware imperfections, likely owing to its more budget-friendly pricing. But overall construction is satisfactory for most users.
So if maximizing precision is crucial or you’ll be running intensive production workloads, the XTool P2’s heavier-duty construction may suit your needs better. Casual users will likely be very happy with the Monport 80W’s build quality though, especially considering its lower cost.
Work Bed & Material Handling
The XTool P2 55W also offers nicer features for material loading and handling:
- Its work bed has a honeycomb design that helps securely hold down thinner materials. The Monport 80W Laser has a solid aluminum work plate.
- The P2 includes three spring-loaded material clamps for quickly securing workpieces. The Monport 80W Laser does not include any clamps.
- The P2 has a wider pass-through slot at 14 cm x 70 cm, better accommodating complex shapes and multi-part assemblies. The Monport 80W’s slot measures 7.5 cm x 95 cm.
Finally, the P2’s rotary add-on allows engraving glasses, mugs and other cylindrical objects. Monport does not currently offer a rotary engraving module.
So if ease of use and flexibility are important, the XTool P2 55W provides better material handling and workaround options out of the box. But the Monport 80W’s larger pass-through can fit longer workpieces.
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Software & Connectivity
Ease of setup and integration with your existing design software are also important considerations when picking a laser engraver.
The XTool P2 55W pairs with XTool Creative Space (XCS), a full-featured creation and laser control application for Windows and Mac. The software is beginner-friendly but packs advanced capabilities like AI assisted functions, design templates & plugins to extend its functionality.
XCS also enables wireless control of the P2 from iOS and Android mobile devices. This allows monitoring engraving jobs and controlling basics like start/stop/pause without being tethered to your computer.
The Monport 80W Laser is controlled through third-party software like RDWorks, LightBurn or CorelLaser (none is included). These programs offer similar core functionality to XCS but may present a steeper learning curve, especially for first-time laser users.
And without dedicated iOS/Android apps, Monport machines require connecting to a Windows or Mac computer to operate.
So the XTool P2 solution offers tighter hardware-software integration and flexibility through wireless connectivity. But if you already own engraving software licenses, the Monport 80W Laser can leverage your existing workflows.
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Ease of Use
When it comes to getting set up and running quickly, the XTool P2 55W also has some distinct advantages:
Intelligent Camera Focusing System
The XTool P2 has dual 16MP cameras with integrated AI:
- A panoramic camera visually previews the entire work area for easy material positioning
- A close-range camera syncs with the laser for distortion-free imaging and precision focusing
Together these allow automatically constructing 3D models of curved objects for engraving. And the system can intelligently recognize shapes to batch engrave multiples based on the available space.
The Monport 80W Laser relies on manual focus testing by raising/lowering the work bed and using an included acrylic focusing tool. So properly focusing takes more effort, especially for curved or irregularly shaped pieces.
Guided Laser Setup
Setting up laser engravers typically involves carefully aligning mirrors and lenses along the laser path for optimum efficiency and precision.
The XTool P2 55W has automated routines to guide users through calibration and alignment. So fine-tuning the hardware is straightforward for beginners and infrequent users.
Monport owners will need to periodically perform manual calibration to keep their laser paths dialed in. This requires using special adjustment tools & following detailed mechanical procedures.
Simplified Network Connectivity
Finally, the XTool P2 enables direct wireless connection to home or office WiFi networks.
The Monport 80W Laser currently only supports wired Ethernet or USB connections. So users are limited to working near their router/switch or within the length of a USB cable.
Together these capabilities make the XTool P2 55W easier to start using out of the box compared to the Monport 80W Laser. So it’s better suited for anyone who wants to spend more time creating and less time adjusting and tweaking their laser engraver.
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Safety Features
Since CO2 laser engravers produce intense heat and radiation during operation, adequate safety protections are crucial – especially for home or office use.
Both Monport and XTool aim to minimize risks with enclosed housings and emergency stop buttons that quickly cut power. Additional safety features Include:
XTool P2 55W
- Class 1 laser option for reduced radiation output
- Automatic lid locking during operation
- Overheating and water flow alerts
- Compatible fire detection & suppression accessories
- Acrylic viewing window with metal frame
- Water leak & exhaust fan detection
- Automatic shutdown if lid is opened
So while both models check the core safety requirement boxes, the XTool P2 55W goes further to actively monitor operation and prevent unsafe conditions from occurring.
For anyone wanting maximum peace of mind – especially households with children or high-traffic workspaces – the XTool P2 provides better real-time safeguards.
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Warranties & Customer Support
Given their technical complexity, it’s important that laser engravers come with responsive customer support and adequate warranty coverage. Here’s how XTool and Monport compare:
- XTool P2 55W warranty – 2 years on machine, 1 year on laser tube
- Monport 80W warranty – 2 years on machine, 1 year on laser tube
So base warranty coverage is identical. Both also offer lifetime technical support via email.
Hands-on reviews praise XTool’s customer service for prompt, helpful guidance installing, operating and troubleshooting their laser engravers.
Monport also aims to respond within 24 hours and receives positive remarks for knowledgeable assistance. Though a few users reported delays receiving replies.
On balance though, most owners are happy with the level of support provided by both manufacturers. Just be sure to buy from authorized sellers so you don’t run into warranty issues down the road.
XTool vs Monport 80W Laser: Cost Comparison
The final key consideration is pricing and overall value for money. Here’s how the base XTool P2 55W and Monport 80W Laser engraver models compare:
- XTool P2 55W – $4,499 USD
- Monport 80W – $3,999 USD
So for $500 more, the XTool P2 55W justifies its pricing premium through smarter hardware features like dual-cam auto-focus and calibration, rugged metal construction, dedicated operating software and wireless control.
|What is the Best Laser Engraver for Yeti Cups in 2024?
|Revolutionize Your Engraving Game with xTool P2 Lightburn!
|AtomStack X20 Pro vs xTool D1 Pro: Which is the Best Laser?
|The 10 Ultimate Tumbler Engraving Machine in 2023
However the Monport 80W Laser holds its own with excellent CO2 laser cutting and engraving performance at 20% higher peak power. And it manages to shave a nice chunk off the price too.
For buyers on tighter budgets who don’t necessarily need state-of-the-art bells and whistles, the Monport 80W Laser supplies fantastic value. But the extra dollars bring some very practical benefits with the XTool P2 55W for both novice makers and production-focused professionals.
XTool P2 vs Monport 80W Laser: Which is Better for You?
So now that we’ve compared every facet of these two capable CO2 laser engravers, which is the right pick for your needs?
Choose the XTool P2 55W if you want:
- Smart camera-based auto-focus and calibration
- Greater engraving precision
- Simple wireless connectivity
- Easier novice-friendly operation
- Rugged metal enclosure
- Expanded material handling options
Choose the Monport 80W Laser if you want:
- Higher peak laser power
- Larger pass-through size
- Very affordable pricing
- Slightly wider material support
- Smaller footprint
For most home crafters, hobbyists and online sellers, the XTool P2 55W CO2 Laser Engraver makes an excellent choice that won’t break the bank. Convenient wireless control, precision auto-focus and robust metal construction make it a great long-term investment.
But businesses and professional makers who prioritize pure laser cutting ability may benefit from the Monport 80W Laser model and its upgraded 80W tube and 36 x 24” engraving area. Just be prepared for a bit steeper learning curve getting up and running.
One final tip is to check both XTool and Monport’s websites for the latest sales and bundled packages too. XTool frequently offers their P2 engraver with conveyers, smoke filters or materials to boost value. While Monport bundles can add handy accessories like air pumps and materials.
Unleash Your Creativity in 2024 with a Desktop CO2 Laser Engraver
Adding a CO2 laser engraver like the XTool P2 55W or Monport 80W Laser can bring your creative ideas to life with incredible precision and detail across wood, acrylic, paper, leather and much more.
We hope this detailed comparison has helped highlight which model best fits your artistic vision, skills & budget for all kinds of engraving &creation needs.
Here’s to an amazing 2024 and beyond of designing & making!
Which features set XTool P2 apart?
The XTool P2 boasts superior precision with its advanced laser technology, offering intricate engraving capabilities for your projects.
What makes Monport 80W Laser stand out?
Monport 80W impresses with its powerful performance, delivering high-speed engraving and cutting, making it an ideal choice for efficiency and productivity.
How user-friendly is XTool P2?
XTool P2 is designed for user convenience, featuring an intuitive interface and easy-to-use controls, making it suitable for beginners and experienced users alike.
Is Monport 80W suitable for diverse materials?
Yes, Monport 80W is versatile, handling various materials like wood, acrylic, and more, ensuring a broad range of applications for your creative projects.
Which machine is more cost-effective in the long run?
Considering its durability and efficient energy use, XTool P2 offers a cost-effective solution, providing excellent value over time compared to Monport 80W.